Holiday Mulled Cider

Mulled Cider warming in a crockpot

This has been an autumn favorite for my family for years! Before we had kids, my wife and I would make a batch every Halloween night to enjoy while handing out candy and cuddling up to watch the live Ghost Hunters broadcasts. Now that we have kids, the tradition has evolved a bit — we still make it on Halloween night to sip while trick-or-treating, and we love sharing a warm mug with our neighbors.

Choose "Save as PDF" in the print window to download it.

Serves 10 to 20 Prep 15 minutes Cook 4 to 4½ hours

Ingredients

  • 1 gallon Ziegler’s apple cider (grab a second gallon for refills)
  • 1 cup brown sugar
  • 1 orange
  • 1 Granny Smith apple
  • 1 to 1½ cups Christian Brothers VSOP brandy (or rum, if you prefer)
  • 2 cinnamon sticks
  • 2 whole star anise pods
  • 8 to 10 whole cloves
  • About 2 tablespoons mulled wine spice
  • A pinch of allspice

You’ll also need: a slow cooker, cheesecloth or a spice bag, and a microplane.

Prep

Apple

Wash the apple and cut it into slivers, removing the seeds and core. About ¾ of the apple goes in the slow cooker. The other ¼ is for eating while you work.

Orange

  • Zest the orange first. The more zest, the more citrusy the cider, so zest to taste. Stay out of the white part; it’s bitter.
  • Set the zest aside (or toss it straight into the slow cooker).
  • Slice the orange into ¼″ to ⅜″ rounds.
  • “Spike” 2 or 3 slices by pushing the cloves into the peel. The rest of the orange is also for eating while you work.

Spices

Put about 2 tablespoons (roughly a third of the jar) of mulled wine spice into a spice bag or tie it up in cheesecloth.

Mull

  1. Set the slow cooker to HIGH.
  2. Pour in 1 gallon of cider.
  3. Add the brown sugar and stir until it dissolves.
  4. Add the brandy (or rum).
  5. Add a pinch of allspice directly to the cider.
  6. Grate some cinnamon into the cider with the microplane, then drop in what’s left of the sticks.
  7. Add the apple slices.
  8. Add the clove-spiked orange slices and the zest.
  9. Add the spice bag.
  10. Add the 2 star anise pods directly to the cider.
  11. Let it mull on HIGH for about 3 to 3½ hours, then switch to LOW (or WARM) for another hour or so. Don’t let it boil.

James’s tip: go easy on the allspice. Too much will ruin it. Trust me.

Serve

  • Serve warm in a glass or mug. A cinnamon stick makes a nice garnish.
  • When the cider gets down to about half, top the slow cooker back up to about ¾ full with more cider, and add more brandy if needed. 😉
  • 1 gallon serves 10 to 20 guests. Unless they love it (and they will), then maybe 10 or so.