
This has been an autumn favorite for my family for years! Before we had kids, my wife and I would make a batch every Halloween night to enjoy while handing out candy and cuddling up to watch the live Ghost Hunters broadcasts. Now that we have kids, the tradition has evolved a bit — we still make it on Halloween night to sip while trick-or-treating, and we love sharing a warm mug with our neighbors.
Ingredients
- 1 gallon Ziegler’s apple cider (grab a second gallon for refills)
- 1 cup brown sugar
- 1 orange
- 1 Granny Smith apple
- 1 to 1½ cups Christian Brothers VSOP brandy (or rum, if you prefer)
- 2 cinnamon sticks
- 2 whole star anise pods
- 8 to 10 whole cloves
- About 2 tablespoons mulled wine spice
- A pinch of allspice
You’ll also need: a slow cooker, cheesecloth or a spice bag, and a microplane.
Prep
Apple
Wash the apple and cut it into slivers, removing the seeds and core. About ¾ of the apple goes in the slow cooker. The other ¼ is for eating while you work.
Orange
- Zest the orange first. The more zest, the more citrusy the cider, so zest to taste. Stay out of the white part; it’s bitter.
- Set the zest aside (or toss it straight into the slow cooker).
- Slice the orange into ¼″ to ⅜″ rounds.
- “Spike” 2 or 3 slices by pushing the cloves into the peel. The rest of the orange is also for eating while you work.
Spices
Put about 2 tablespoons (roughly a third of the jar) of mulled wine spice into a spice bag or tie it up in cheesecloth.
Mull
- Set the slow cooker to HIGH.
- Pour in 1 gallon of cider.
- Add the brown sugar and stir until it dissolves.
- Add the brandy (or rum).
- Add a pinch of allspice directly to the cider.
- Grate some cinnamon into the cider with the microplane, then drop in what’s left of the sticks.
- Add the apple slices.
- Add the clove-spiked orange slices and the zest.
- Add the spice bag.
- Add the 2 star anise pods directly to the cider.
- Let it mull on HIGH for about 3 to 3½ hours, then switch to LOW (or WARM) for another hour or so. Don’t let it boil.
James’s tip: go easy on the allspice. Too much will ruin it. Trust me.
Serve
- Serve warm in a glass or mug. A cinnamon stick makes a nice garnish.
- When the cider gets down to about half, top the slow cooker back up to about ¾ full with more cider, and add more brandy if needed. 😉
- 1 gallon serves 10 to 20 guests. Unless they love it (and they will), then maybe 10 or so.
